Why it’s so hard to trust yourself after narcissistic relationships

When your reality has been questioned over time, it can leave you doubting your own thoughts and feelings. This post explores why self-trust becomes so difficult—and how it can be rebuilt.

There’s a moment many people reach after a difficult relationship.

Not always straight away.
Sometimes much later.

Where they realise they don’t quite trust themselves anymore.

Not just the other person—but their own thoughts, feelings, and decisions.

And that can feel unsettling in a way that’s hard to explain.


It doesn’t happen all at once

Losing trust in yourself isn’t usually a single event.

It happens gradually.

Small moments where something doesn’t feel right…
but you explain it away.

Times where you question your reaction…
or are told you’ve misunderstood.

Situations where your reality is challenged…
or gently rewritten.

Over time, those moments build.

Until instead of asking “What’s happening here?”
you start asking:
“Is this my fault?”
“Am I overreacting?”


Confusion becomes normal

One of the most common things people describe is confusion.

Not knowing what to think.
Not knowing what’s real.
Going over conversations again and again.

Trying to piece things together.

And often assuming that confusion means you’re missing something.

But in these kinds of dynamics, confusion isn’t always a lack of understanding.

Sometimes, it’s a response to inconsistency.


Your internal signals get overridden

At some point, many people start to override their own instincts.

That feeling in your body that something isn’t right…
gets pushed aside.

You might tell yourself:

  • “I’m reading too much into this”
  • “I need to be more understanding”
  • “I don’t want to make things worse”

So instead of moving towards your own experience, you move away from it.

And the more that happens, the quieter your internal voice can become.


You learn to look outward for answers

When your own perspective has been questioned enough times, it’s natural to start looking elsewhere.

For reassurance.
For clarity.
For someone to tell you what’s real.

You might find yourself:

  • checking how others would interpret things
  • needing validation before making decisions
  • doubting even small choices

Not because you’re incapable.

But because your trust in yourself has been slowly worn down.


It’s not a lack of strength

This is often where people are hardest on themselves.

“How did I not see it?”
“Why did I stay?”
“Why can’t I just trust myself again?”

But this isn’t about weakness.

It’s about being in a dynamic where your reality wasn’t consistently reflected back to you in a steady, safe way.

Anyone in that environment long enough would start to question themselves.


Rebuilding self-trust takes time

Trusting yourself again doesn’t usually come back in one moment.

It’s slower than that.

It might start with very small things:

  • noticing how something feels in your body
  • allowing a reaction without immediately dismissing it
  • making a decision without asking for reassurance

Not forcing certainty.
Just allowing your own experience to exist.


A different starting point

Instead of asking:
“Can I trust myself?”

It can sometimes help to start with:
“What am I noticing?”

That shifts the focus away from getting it right—and towards reconnecting with yourself.


You haven’t lost it

If you’re struggling to trust yourself after a relationship like this, it can feel like something has been broken.

But often, it hasn’t disappeared.

It’s just been overridden for a while.

And with time, space, and the right kind of support, it can come back.

Not as something loud or certain.

But as something quieter.

Steady.

And your own.

Share your love
Sarah Phipps
Sarah Phipps

I’m Sarah Phipps, a BACP Accredited pluralistic therapist working with adults who are navigating the impact of childhood trauma, anxiety, depression, and narcissistic abuse. I offer a calm, non-judgmental space where you can begin to make sense of your experiences at your own pace. My approach is collaborative and neuroaffirming, and I work with people of all backgrounds, identities, and neurotypes. I aim to meet you as you are, helping you reconnect with yourself and move forward in a way that feels more grounded, understood, and your own.

Articles: 10

Discover more from Hope Tree Counselling

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading